Why Diets Fail Without Consistency and Accountability

Dave Delbecchi • August 6, 2025

How a Nutrition Coach Can Help.

Every year, millions of people start a new diet full of determination to lose weight and get healthy. Yet research shows that 80–95% of dieters regain the weight within 12 months. Why do most diets fail? It’s not simply lack of willpower—it’s a lack of consistency, accountability, and proper nutrition planning.

In this post, we’ll explore the science behind why diets fail, why working with a nutrition coach improves success rates, and how understanding calories and macros can finally help you achieve lasting fat loss.


Why Diets Fail Without Consistency


Many diets start strong but quickly fade because they rely on short-term, restrictive approaches that aren’t sustainable. Crash dieting slows your metabolism, causes intense cravings, and often leads to regaining even more weight than before.

Studies show that consistency—not perfection—is the key to fat loss. Small, repeatable habits like balanced meals, portion control, and regular check-ins outperform strict “all-or-nothing” dieting. Without structure and support, most people fall back into old eating patterns.


The Role of Accountability in Successful Fat Loss


A 2016 study published in Obesity found that people who had regular coaching check-ins were 65% more likely to maintain weight loss than those who tried to do it alone. Accountability works because:

  • You have someone tracking progress and adjusting your plan

  • Motivation stays high even when willpower dips

  • A coach helps you navigate challenges like social events or busy schedules

Accountability isn’t just about reminders—it’s about having a partner who ensures you follow through on your goals long enough for habits to take hold.


Why Working With a Nutrition Coach Gets Better Results


A skilled nutrition coach doesn’t just hand you a meal plan. They:

  • Teach Habit-Based Nutrition: Sustainable change happens through small, consistent habits, not drastic diets.

  • Customize Plans: Every client’s needs, lifestyle, and metabolism are different. A coach adjusts your plan based on your progress.

  • Provide Ongoing Support: Regular check-ins keep you focused and help you overcome obstacles that would otherwise derail progress.


Calories Matter—But Macros Matter More


Most people know that weight loss depends on calories in vs. calories out. But the quality of those calories matters just as much as the quantity.

  • Protein: Preserves lean muscle while losing fat (recommended 0.7–1.0g per lb of body weight).

  • Carbohydrates: Provide energy for workouts and daily activity.

  • Fats: Essential for hormones and feeling full but should be balanced to avoid excess calories.

Weighing and measuring food helps build awareness of portions and ensures you’re hitting the right macro targets. Research shows that people who track their intake lose up to twice as much weight as those who don’t.


Final Thoughts


Diets don’t fail because you’re not trying hard enough—they fail because they lack the structure, accountability, and understanding of proper nutrition needed for lasting success.

Working with a nutrition coach gives you the tools to stay consistent, build sustainable habits, and master the balance of calories and macros for long-term fat loss.



More Posts

Earn Your Intensity

By Dave Delbecchi • August 24, 2025
Earn Your Intensity. What does that really mean? The word earn can sound harsh—like we’re telling someone they don’t deserve something. But in CrossFit, “earning your intensity” is about respecting the process. It’s built on the foundation we always come back to: technique first, consistency second, and intensity last. If you focus on improving your technique and applying it consistently, then over time you truly earn the right to add intensity. And here, I’m speaking specifically about heavy lifting. Cardio has its own demands, but let’s stay with lifting for now. Take the back squat as an example. If you haven’t mastered a solid air squat—chest tall, hips below parallel, knees tracking properly—why would you expect to move heavy weight safely? If you can’t do the basics well, you haven’t yet earned the right to go heavy. When I say earn the right, it’s not about me telling you what you can or can’t do. You’re an adult. It’s really a question: has your technique and consistency prepared your body for the demands of heavier loads? Has your strength and mobility built up enough to handle the position safely? If not, then the smartest path forward is simple: refine your squat. Keep working at lower intensities on both strength days and in workouts. That way, you’ll improve movement quality, break old habits, and address mobility limitations. Sometimes it’s not a lack of strength—it’s just that you’ve gotten comfortable with “your version” of the squat instead of chasing a better one. By focusing on technique first, two things will happen: you’ll get stronger, and you’ll reduce your risk of injury. That’s why it’s worth taking the time to earn your intensity. So the next time you approach a heavy lift, remember—it’s not about how much weight you want to put on the bar. It’s about what you’ve earned through consistent, quality movement.

The Power Of Choice

By Dave Delbecchi • March 2, 2025
The book Smarter, Faster, Better breaks down motivation into one key principle: self-determination. The more control you have over your decisions, the more drive you will have to follow through. Studies show that people are far more likely to complete difficult tasks when they see them as a choice rather than a command. When you connect your actions—whether it’s a workout, eating more protein, or skipping junk food—to a bigger goal, everything becomes easier. This program has been about taking control. You made the choice to prioritize your health, eat well, and train with intention. Keep asking yourself why—why did you start? Why does it matter? The more you connect your daily habits to a larger purpose, the easier they are to sustain. CONSISTENCY WINS Forget perfection. The goal is to get it right most of the time. The difference between someone who sticks to their plan 100% and someone who hits 80-90%? Barely noticeable results—but a massive difference in sustainability. That’s why you need a system that works for your life: The 80/20 Rule – Stick to whole, nutritious foods 80-90% of the time, and allow 10-20% flexibility for social events, favourite meals, or just enjoying life. That’s 2-4 relaxed meals per week—so use them wisely. Make healthy eating easier than unhealthy eating – Set up your environment for success. Plan meals, batch cook, and keep real food within reach. Control your home environment – Don’t bring temptations into your house. You can indulge occasionally, but don’t make it a daily battle. The key to long-term success isn’t willpower—it’s systems. Set yourself up to win. Stay consistent, keep it simple, and take control of your choices. You’ve got this.
CrossFit Coach's view on scaling and the intended stimulus of workouts

Why Sticking To The Stimulus Matters - A Coach's View

By Dave Delbecchi • November 13, 2024
Teaching the intent behind workouts and why it matters for results.
SHOW MORE